Pet-Friendly Rentals in Ontario: Pros and Cons for Landlords

Opening your rental property to furry or feathered companions can be a decision with significant implications for Ontario landlords. While welcoming pets can attract a broader pool of tenants, it also raises unique challenges. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of allowing pets in your Ontario rental property, helping you make an informed decision.

The Appeal of Pet-Friendly Rentals

Allowing pets in your rental property broadens your potential tenant base significantly. Many responsible pet owners struggle to find suitable accommodations that accept pets, making your property more attractive to a broader audience.

Pros of Pet-Friendly Rentals

Higher Demand: Pet-friendly rentals are in high demand, particularly among pet owners who face limited housing options due to restrictions on pet ownership. By welcoming pets, you increase the demand for your property, potentially leading to shorter vacancy periods.
Increased Rent Potential: You can often charge higher rent or request additional pet deposits or fees from tenants with pets. These extra charges can boost your rental income, helping to offset any potential pet-related costs.
Longer Tenant Stay: Pet owners tend to stay longer in pet-friendly rentals. They are often more reluctant to disrupt their pets’ routines by moving frequently. Longer tenant stays reduce turnover, which means fewer vacancies and associated costs.

Legal Considerations in Ontario

In Ontario, landlords cannot discriminate against tenants based on their possession of a pet. The Ontario Human Rights Code protects individuals from discrimination based on factors such as creed, disability, and family status, which includes pet ownership. This means you cannot refuse to rent to someone solely because they have a pet.

Tenant Responsibilities

Clear Pet Guidelines: It’s crucial to establish clear pet guidelines within your lease agreement. These guidelines should outline tenant responsibilities for pet care, including cleaning up after their pets, preventing damage, and ensuring their pets do not disturb other tenants.
Pet Deposits or Fees: To cover potential pet-related damages or cleaning costs, you may consider charging pet deposits or monthly fees. These funds can be held separately from the security deposit and used if necessary for repairs or cleaning due to pet-related issues.

Cons of Pet-Friendly Rentals

Property Damage Risk: While not all pets cause damage, there is a risk of pet-related property damage, including scratches on floors or walls, stains on carpets, and lingering odors. Landlords should be prepared to address these issues.
Allergy Concerns: Some individuals may have allergies to pets, which could limit the pool of applicants interested in your property. It’s important to consider how you’ll accommodate prospective tenants with allergies.
Noise Complaints: Pets can sometimes be noisy, leading to complaints from other tenants. Landlords should have a process in place for addressing noise complaints promptly and effectively.

Insurance and Liability

Landlord Insurance: Landlords should review their landlord insurance policy to ensure it covers potential pet-related incidents. Some policies may require specific provisions for pet-friendly rentals.
Liability: Consider the liability concerns associated with pets on the property. If a pet injures another tenant or damages their property, the injured party may seek compensation. It’s essential to understand your liability and whether tenants’ renters insurance covers these situations.

Property Maintenance

Cleaning and Maintenance: Pet-friendly rentals typically require more frequent cleaning and maintenance to address pet-related issues, such as pet hair, odors, and accidents. Landlords should be prepared to invest in regular cleaning to maintain the property’s condition.
Landscaping Considerations: Pets can affect outdoor areas, such as lawns or gardens, through activities like digging or urine spots. Landlords may need to make accommodations or establish rules for outdoor pet behavior.

Screening Pet Owners

Tenant Screening: When considering tenants with pets, landlords should conduct thorough tenant screening, which includes checking references from previous landlords. This can help gauge the tenant’s responsibility as a pet owner and their history of pet-related issues.
Meet the Pet: Meeting the pet before approving the tenant is a good practice. This allows you to assess its behavior, size, and temperament, which can help you make an informed decision regarding its suitability for your property.

Pet Policies and Rules

Pet Policies: Landlords should establish clear pet policies that outline pet size limits, breed restrictions (if any), and specific rules for pet ownership within the rental property. These policies should be communicated to tenants and included in the lease agreement.
Pet Agreement Addendum: Consider using a pet agreement addendum to the lease, which can specify pet-related terms and responsibilities. This addendum can serve as a legally binding document that outlines the tenant’s obligations and consequences for non-compliance.

Dealing with Pet-Related Issues

Handling Complaints: Landlords should have a process in place for handling pet-related complaints from tenants promptly and professionally. This may involve addressing issues with the pet owner or, in extreme cases, pursuing legal action if the situation cannot be resolved amicably.
Pet Damage Costs: In the event of pet-related damage beyond normal wear and tear, landlords should have a clear process for deducting costs from security deposits or fees. This process should adhere to Ontario’s tenancy laws and regulations to ensure fairness and transparency.

Deciding whether to allow pets in your Ontario rental property involves weighing the potential benefits against the challenges. By understanding the legal framework, implementing clear pet policies, and carefully screening pet-owning tenants, you can create a successful and harmonious pet-friendly rental environment that benefits both landlords and responsible pet owners.

Have Any Questions?

Or chat with an agent on our live chat in the bottom right corner.